How Recruiting is…How Recruiting is like Romance

Hiring Manager Hacks 2.7.24

How Recruiting is like Romance

  • Brady Hitchcock
  • 02/07/2024
  • Find Talent

Valentine’s Day is one week away!


You’re welcome for the reminder. Or I apologize for bringing it up.


Either way, it’s happening. And we hope you have a happy one...


Love is in the air and this time of year we are reminded how much recruiting is like romance. Forget the pressure of perfectly curated online profiles and the awkwardness of blind dates. The real search for compatibility isn't happening in dimly lit restaurants and trendy cafes but in the fluorescent-lit offices and conference rooms of corporate America. Finding great employees and building a team you love share surprising similarities with the delicate dance of finding a romantic match.


The Job Posting: Putting Yourself Out There

Much like creating an enticing dating profile, the job posting sets the stage for attracting potential employees. The employer crafts a description that showcases the company's personality, values, and expectations. Just as an individual highlights their interests, values, and what they're seeking in a partner, the job posting outlines the qualifications, skills, and attributes the company desires in a candidate.

In the world of relationships, this is comparable to the initial attraction phase. A well-crafted dating profile captures attention, much like a carefully articulated job posting attracts the right candidates. The employer aims to communicate the company's unique qualities and values, enticing individuals who resonate with the organization's culture.


The Application: I’ve Been Waiting for a Job Like You
When potential candidates come across a compelling job posting, they express interest by submitting an application. Similarly, in the dating world, individuals may express their interest by reaching out online or responding to a DM. The application process serves as the first step in gauging compatibility, as candidates provide basic information about their skills, experience, and qualifications.
Just as in a romantic context where an individual showcases their personality through messages and interactions, candidates use their applications to present their professional personas. The employer evaluates the application to determine if there's potential for a meaningful connection, drawing parallels to the early stages of getting to know someone through online messages or initial conversations.


The Resume: Getting to Know You

Resumes and dating profiles are both curated snapshots designed to make a positive impression. In the professional realm, a resume outlines a candidate's educational background, work experience, and skills. Similarly, a dating profile highlights an individual's interests, hobbies, and qualities (living your best life!). Both documents aim to showcase the best aspects of the person, providing a glimpse into what makes them unique and valuable.

Just as a resume provides a structured overview of a candidate's professional journey, a dating profile offers insights into an individual's life story. Employers, like potential partners, analyze these documents to discern compatibility and alignment with their needs. This stage is akin to discovering common interests and shared values during the early stages of a relationship.

(Yes, at this point, and for our purposes we’re assuming that anyone who wants to date these days uses dating apps or starts things off online one way or another. Check out some actual dating data from Forbes.)


The Initial Screening and Interview Process: Peeling Back the Layers
As the dating process progresses beyond initial messages, candidates move into the interview phase. This stage is analogous to the early dates in a romantic relationship. The employer delves deeper into the candidate's personality, skills, and experiences, seeking to understand if there's a genuine connection.
The interview process is a dynamic exchange where both parties assess compatibility. Employers ask probing questions to understand a candidate's motivations, work style, and problem-solving abilities. Similarly, individuals on a date explore each other's values, interests, and life goals. This mutual exploration is essential for determining if there's a strong foundation for a lasting connection.
Just as in a budding romance where first impressions matter, the interview phase allows employers to gauge a candidate's interpersonal skills and cultural fit. The employer evaluates not only the candidate's qualifications but also their potential contribution to the team dynamic. This mirrors the personal relationship dynamic, where individuals assess if there's chemistry and alignment beyond surface-level compatibility. The dreaded “meet the parents” stage of dating.


The Job Offer and Acceptance: Sealing the Deal

After a successful series of interviews, the employer extends a job offer to the chosen candidate. This moment is akin to a romantic relationship reaching a point where one person decides to make a commitment. The job offer signifies a desire for a long-term professional connection, like the decision to enter into a committed personal partnership.

Much like accepting a romantic partner's proposal, the candidate's acceptance of the job offer solidifies the commitment. It marks the beginning of a shared journey where both parties are invested in mutual growth and success. The terms of employment and expectations are laid out, much like the discussions that take place as a couple establishes the foundations of their relationship.

In both scenarios, this stage involves a blending of expectations, negotiations, and a shared vision for the future. The employer and employee embark on a collaborative journey, where trust, communication, and commitment are essential for a successful partnership.


Retention: Happily Ever After
Just as a successful romantic relationship requires ongoing effort, maintaining a strong professional connection goes beyond the initial stages of attraction and acceptance. The retention phase is comparable to the journey of sustaining a lasting partnership.
In the workplace, retention involves actively understanding and addressing employees' evolving needs. Regular check-ins, professional development, and a supportive environment contribute to a sense of belonging and commitment. Employers who prioritize retention invest in initiatives that align with their employees' values, fostering a positive and enduring work culture.
Similarly, in personal relationships, ongoing communication is vital for understanding each other's changing needs and expectations. Employers, like partners, engage in open dialogue to address challenges, provide feedback, and celebrate successes. Performance reviews, mentorship programs, and opportunities for growth create a collaborative environment conducive to long-term success.
Acknowledging the importance of retention underscores a commitment to building enduring connections. Employers who invest in the well-being and growth of their employees foster loyalty, just as partners who actively nurture their relationship enjoy a fulfilling and lasting bond.


If you’re directly involved in the process all the time, as we are, you get how painfully deep this whole analogy runs. At Spectrum, we refer to ourselves as “matchmakers”. We facilitate and promote relationships between job seekers and hiring managers with all the same enthusiasm we would setting up friends for first dates. In fact, we literally refer to initial interviews between candidates and clients as “first dates”.

By recognizing the similarities between finding great employees and forming a meaningful romantic relationship your company can approach the hiring process holistically, creating a workplace where individuals not only succeed professionally but also thrive long term.

Both recruiting and romance involve a delicate dance of attraction, expression of interest, revealing layers of personality, getting to know each other, and ultimately making a commitment to a shared future. Recognizing these parallels allows employers and candidates alike to approach the hiring process with a deeper understanding of the dynamics at play, fostering connections that are not only professionally rewarding but also personally fulfilling.


Get in touch today to find out how we can help set you up with the best of the best so your company is set up for success after success.


If you’re open to exploring new opportunities rather than hiring, check out our job board here.


You can now choose to receive this HIRING MANAGER HACKS  newsletter every other Wednesday, our NEW JOBS NEWSLETTER on alternating Wednesdays, TOP TALENT candidate spotlights every Tuesday, or ALL OF THE ABOVE.


ENTER YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS HERE to sign up or update your preferences.

Tags: spectrum recruiting, slc recruiters, utah recruiters, manufacturing recruiters, engineering recruiters, valentines day, recruiting and dating, recruiting and romance, Spectrum Recruiting Solutions